MINUTES OF PAST MEETINGS OF THE JEC



Tuesday, 2 March 2010 at 5pm at the Town Office.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



Thursday, 21 January 2010 at 7pm at the Library.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



Thursday, 17 December 2009 at 7pm at the Library.
Thursday, 19 November 2009 at 7pm at the Library.
Thursday, 15 October 2009 at 7pm at the Library.
Thursday, 17 September 2009 at 7pm at 12 Blackberry Lane.
Thursday, 18 June 2009 at 7pm at the Meetinghouse.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



Thursday, 26 March 2009 at 7pm at the Library.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



Thursday, 30 April 2009 at 7pm at the Library.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



January 29, 2009 Meeting

Members present: Dick Ames, Harry Young, Margaret Dillon, Ed Suprenant.
Absent: Doug Clayton, Doug Starr, Bonnie Mitchell, Rob Stephenson, Andy Jones.
Guest: Sarah Harpster, consultant to Clean Air-Cool Planet

The Committee approved Steve Dark of Millipore as a new Committee member.

Harry Young presented an update on the Streetlight Committee's work. The Committee has accepted Police Chief Oswalt's recommendation for retention of 10 of the 96 lights that had been initially identified the Committee for removal. The Committee is recommending that the remaining 86 lights be replaced with 70 watt full-cutoff metal halide fixtures. The Committee is scheduled to review its recommendations with the Board of Selectmen on Monday March 2. [Note: Due to snow, the review meeting with the Selectmen took place on March 3.]

Sarah Harpster reported on Clean Air Cool Planet's program to support local energy committees. She encouraged our Committee to complete its baseline energy assessment, preferably using 2005 data (to provide a baseline comparable to other towns) and will send a excel program to Dick Ames which will facilitate this work.

The Committee reviewed the RFP that has recently been issued by the Public Utilities Commission for projects that will be funded by the new Greenhouse Gas Emissions Fund, a product of New Hampshire's participation in the auctioning of renewable energy credits through the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. The Committee agreed to ask Jaffrey to proceed with a proposal for funding of building energy audits and building energy improvements. In this connection, Margaret Burnham reported that she is scheduled to do a comprehensive energy audit on 3/20 of the Town Offices building, and that this could serve as a model for other energy audits. Margaret also reported on the new International Energy Conservation Code, which includes much stronger provisions for tight and well insulated building envelopes.

Dick Ames presented information on Solar Photovoltaic systems, reported that a 5.1 KW system installed on his roof last June has worked well, proving to be an economically excellent long range investment. He also discussed with the Committee the possibility of installing a large Solar PV system on available open space at the Recycling Center to help meet the 1.4 megawatt hours per year electric power demand of the new water treatment facility (and also to help meet the recycling center's electric power requirements.) [Note: Dick Ames' follow-up memo to the Selectmen on the Solar PV and Building Energy Audit proposals is included at the end of these minutes.]

Dick Ames presented and discussed a memorandum dated 1/29/09 with information on policy, regulatory, funding and other developments of interest. A copy of this memorandum has been circulated to all Committee members.

The next meeting was scheduled for 7 PM, Thursday, March 26, 2009, at the Town Library.

Respectfully submitted by Richard Ames
[See below for follow-up memo to Selectmen.]


Memorandum

To: Members of the Town of Jaffrey Board of Selectmen
From: Richard Ames, Chair, Town of Jaffrey Energy Committee
Re: Energy Savings Opportunities:
- Building Energy Audits & Renovation, and
- Solar PV on Land at the Recycling Center
Date: March 4, 2009

I write to bring to your immediate attention two separate but possibly linked opportunities that could result in significant cost and energy savings for the Town of Jaffrey.

Building Audits and Energy-Saving Renovation
On February 27, 2009, I sent the attached e-mail to Town Manager Michael Hartman, who I understand has been ill and is now on a long-planned vacation. Since time is of the essence, and since I am told that the Board of Selectmen's authorization is needed for work on this project to go forward, I am now bringing this directly to your attention. My e-mail proposed that Jaffrey respond to the DPU's Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction Fund RFP with a proposal for funds to support professional energy audits of Jaffrey's building inventory. The request could also seek funds for implementation of the audit findings. All of this is fully explained in the attached e-mail. The potential for cost and energy savings is considerable. Time to act on this is very short since the funding request must be submitted by March 23, 2009. Funds to examine the Solar PV option discussed below could also be included in this proposal. I can help get this proposal done after I get back from a trip that starts tomorrow and ends on March 11, and I am sure that other Energy Committee members would be willing to help as well.
Solar PV on Recycling Center Property
Solar PV Systems for Municipalities In general: An increasing number of municipalities around the country are establishing solar photovoltaic (PV) collectors to meet in part their need for electric power. They are doing this through "power purchase agreements" (PPAs). In a PPA, a private company installs and owns the PV system pursuant to a long-term contract with a municipality. The company takes advantage of the huge federal tax incentives that are currently available (30% refundable investment tax credit and 5 year accelerated depreciation deduction) and supplies the municipality with all of the electricity produced by the system. Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) may also be sold to further reduce costs. The municipality then gets electricity at a guaranteed price that is below the current utility price and that goes up each year at a rate that is almost certainly less than the erratic and high inflation that will predictably characterize utility pricing. So, the municipality gets a good deal for its electricity with no up-front capital outlay. And, of course, by converting to a clean energy source, the municipality makes a major contribution to greenhouse gas emission reduction efforts. Options for the municipality to purchase the solar system after the write-off period are often built into these PPAs.

Solar PV System for Jaffrey the Opportunity: The estimated electricity usage at the upgraded water treatment plant is about 1,442,000 KWhs/year. This reflects a huge power requirement and the purchase of electricity for it will be hugely expensive. The recycling center (which also must have significant electricity usage) and its wide open land that once was used for land fill is immediately adjacent to the treatment plant. The open land appears to be a very good solar site. The available square footage appears to be sufficient to support a very large installation, sufficient to provide at least a substantial portion of the electricity used by the treatment plant and recycling center. Solar PV works well in Jaffrey. I know this because last summer I installed a 5.1 KW roof-top system (quite large by residential standards) that is producing at a rate that will exceed 5000 KWhs/year, and possibly reach 6000 KWhs/year. My system has proven itself as an economically excellent long-term investment. This will likely be true for Jaffrey as well. For all of these reasons, I think Jaffrey should aggressively investigate this solar PV opportunity.

Solar PV System for Jaffrey Questions to Explore: There are many questions which Jaffrey will need to explore as it investigates the viability of this solar PV opportunity. Does the land at the recycling center have a good solar exposure and orientation? Is it sufficiently stable to support a framework for the PV system? Are there hazardous waste problems that preclude its use? Is there a better site? How will the interconnection with the PSNH grid work (net metering appears to be unavailable for systems above 100 KWs)? Is there an alternative to the PPA in which PSNH would build and own the PV system? Are there legal obstacles that stand in the way of a NH municipality entering into a PPA? Is the alternative of direct ownership of the PV system by Jaffrey financially viable, given that Jaffrey might be able to use Clean Renewable Energy Bonding authority to finance the project at no interest costs to the town, but would not be able to use the federal income tax credits and write-offs that can be accessed through a PPA? What should the terms of a PPA be? Are there providers who would respond to a proposal to build and operate such a system? Are there other federal or state grants or rebates that could help to reduce the capital cost of this project?

How to Pursue this Project?: The Energy Committee and I would welcome an opportunity to discuss this project with the Selectmen and to help find answers to the above questions.

Information about PPA Solar PV Projects: I attach articles about two Solar PV municipal PPA projects in Massachusetts. A very good comprehensive treatment of these projects is "Solar Photovoltaic Financing: Deployment on Public Property by State and Local Governments", that was put out as a technical document in May 2008 by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and is available at the www.nrel.gov website. I understand that a new, updated report from NREL will be out very soon. I also have copies of other informative treatments of the municipal solar PV question.
I hope that we can work together on these projects.




Thursday, 22 May 2008 at 6pm at the Library.
Click here to see the Minutes prepared by Dick Ames.



November 15, 2007 Meeting

Members present: Harry Young, Doug Clayton, Margaret Dillon, Bonnie Mitchell, Andy Jones, Dick Ames, Ed Surprenant.

1. Introductions: Doug introduced Ed, who told us a bit about himself and that he is working to be LEED certified.

2. Minutes of previous meeting accepted with modifying number 2 Baseline Report to say: 9 months of town electric use data collected and get the previous 3 months to make 1 year of data.

3. Building Codes: Dick was able to contact Peterborough and presented a list of green initiatives that Peterborough is working on. Peterborough is setting up a meeting with Epping and Dick will try to attend as well. There was considerable discussion on how energy efficient we want to get the Town's code. Energy Star compliant code would be a great step since it includes thermal bypass checklists. We would need to do educational training to help ensure that the codes are enforced, especially the thermal bypass checklists. The question was asked if the Town could provide incentives to builders who comply with LEEDs without making this mandatory.
Education became an area of focus in this discussion and the following steps were proposed:
- Enforce existing code
- Educate code officers, builders, home owners, Town officials
- Find one Town building we can retrofit and use to educate and show the positive impact
- We'll probably need to get the materials donated.
Margaret presented a graph showing Town use of propane and heating oil for Jan through May. This started the discussion on which Town building would best suit our purposes as a project demonstration site, including a workshop day as part of the education process. We decided that we need more information to determine the best Town building where we'll get the best return on investment.

4. Streetlight Proposal: Doug talked with some Town officials and with PSNH and found that our town spends over $43,000 per year on streetlights. If the Town switched to all sodium lights, it would save approximately $17,000 per year in electricity costs. This could be done with no upfront costs since there are financing plans available. There was some discussion on the best way to get the Town to convert to more energy efficient streetlights.

Dick agreed to talk with Doug Starr about streetlights.

Harry and Doug will schedule a meeting with our new Town Manager to talk about streetlights.

5. DVD Library: Discussion tabled until next meeting.

6. Budget Request: We will ask for $500 in Town Budget. Harry agreed to write up and submit our request.

7. Legislation: Discussion on difficulties of legislating behaviors. Better approach might be, using shopping bags as an example, to provide incentives to use green alternatives versus the higher cost of using plastic.

8. Old Business: None

9. New Business: An area for us to discuss is recycling and land fill use. Ed agreed to start researching these areas and will talk with Keene.

10. Cocktail Party, Friday December 14, 5:30 PM at Harry's (125 Jaquith Rd).
Be ready to talk about your vision for our committee for the next 6 months.

Our next meeting is scheduled for 6:00 PM on Thursday, Jan 17, 2008 in the Library.



October 25, 2007 Meeting

Members present: Harry Young, Doug Clayton, Margaret Dillon, Bonnie Mitchell, Andy Jones, Dick Ames, Rosemary Duggan

1. Minutes of previous meeting accepted as presented.

2. Baseline Report: Rosemary has collected 8 months of town electric use data. The committee asked her to get the previous 4 months to make 1 year of data. Rosemary will also try to get town data for fuel use (oil/gas/propane).

3. Town Energy Report: Margaret is working this - she'll report back at the next meeting.

4. Building Codes: Discussion on how much we want to recommend and what impact new codes will have on building in our town and the contractors that typically work here.

The State of NH has come out with slightly improved Energy Codes, which took effect in Aug 2007. Many contractors work regionally or even cover the whole state, so it might be beneficial for us to try to work with other towns in our region so code improvements would have more impact.

The main thrust of our discussion was that we should look to beef up building envelope code, for both residential and commercial construction. Tighter codes mean more work up front, such as an Air Seal Test, but the return on investment is significant

Rosemary agreed to look up other state codes such as FL, NJ, OR, PA, VT.

Dick will contact Peterborough, Keene and Epping for more info on their efforts. Margaret will chart info to present options.

5. Committee Expenses - Budget line Item: Have ideas for our next meeting. Possibilities: Education/Presentation expenses? We'll decide and turn in our request to the Town in Nov in time for the budget.

6. Committee Liaison: Dick agreed to contact the Planning Board.

7. Streetlight Proposal: Doug C will gather info on new streetlights.

8. End of Suburbia: Should we/could we hold film viewings to help educate the Town and the public? One way would be to have the Library buy appropriate movies that anyone in town could then sign out and watch, plus we'll have access to borrow them. All: bring a list of recommended movies to our next meeting

9. Old Business: None

10. New Business: None

Our next meeting is scheduled for 6:00 PM on Nov 15, 2007 in the Library.



August 15, 2007 Meeting

Members present: Harry Young, Doug Clayton, Margaret Dillon, Rob Stephenson, Andy Jones.

Douglas Starr was announced as a new committee member, but he was unable to attend.

The voting for our committee name resulted in Jaffrey Energy Committee winning by 2 votes.

We discussed a possible domain name for an Internet presence. Rob has already drafted a web page and logo for us. Hell email us the link so we can check these out. Rob also agreed to email us the committees letter to Town Selectmen.

Rob further agreed to talk with Mark Kresge about getting us space on the Towns Web site.

We brainstormed ideas and concepts for our mission statement. Margaret and Andy agreed to write an initial draft attempting to incorporate the theme of the town meeting charter vote.

Harry reported on his meeting with Town committees and what was discussed: A free energy audit of Jaffrey Town offices the audit was approved The Town agreed to provide Baseline information on current Town energy consumption, which is critical for formulating goals & to show progress Biodiesel, but the Town still has concerns about the tanks and the possibility of leaks or spills.

Harry was interviewed by the Keene Sentinel the article appeared on the front page of the Aug 24, 2007 issue of The Monadnock Home Companion The interviewer, Amanda Borozinski, welcomes our comments on why we joined this committee and what we hope to accomplish. She can be emailed at: aboro@ptcnh.net

We wrapped up with some group photos for use by the media.

Our next meeting is scheduled for 6:00 PM on Sep 19, 2007 in the Town Hall. (Since rescheduled for 6 PM on Sep 20 in the Library.)